IRONCAD DRAFT 2011

Today IronCAD released the IronCAD Design Collaboration Suite 2011 XG comprising of IRONCAD, INOVATE and a new 2D product called IRONCAD DRAFT priced at $595. Well, actually IRONCAD DRAFT is not a new product. It is a greatly improved and rebranded version CAXA Draft that was bundled with the previous version of IRONCAD.

A little bit of history may help understand this better. CAXA is a Chinese CAD/CAM/PLM provider which has a close strategic partnership with IronCAD. They share development resources. Worldwide sales are operated by IronCAD and sales in China are handled by CAXA. Up until a couple of versions ago, IRONCAD has its own 2D CAD system that was integrated with its flagship IRONCAD 3D MCAD product. That was replaced by CAXA Draft in the last version, which is a popular 2D CAD system in China. At that time IronCAD had promised its customers that CAXA Draft would be improved and integrated more tightly with IRONCAD and INOVATE. It looks like they have delivered on that promise with IRONCAD DRAFT 2011.

For some time now, I have been using a beta of IRONCAD DRAFT 2011 and I like what I see. First things first, IRONCAD DRAFT is not an AutoCAD clone. Well, you can used it as one if you want. But that is not how IronCAD is positioning the product, and for good reason. However, I fear that people will put IRONCAD DRAFT in the category of the AutoCAD clones, which would be very unfortunate.

2D Drafting

IRONCAD DRAFT 2011 is a full blown 2D drafting system. This is what the product looks like. I opened a sample AutoCAD DWG file. However, CAXA has its own native file format with an extension of EXB.

I turned on the command line window. It is turned off by default. The command names and shortcuts are not exactly the same as AutoCAD. For example, “L” starts the line command but “C” does not close the line segments. Also there is something known as an Instance Menu which sits just above the status bar and has command specific controls.

2D Detailing

One of the main strengths of IRONCAD DRAFT 2011 is its ability to create 2D detailing drawings from 3D models. When you click File -> New you get an option to create a IRONCAD 3D Scene or a CAXA Draft 2D drawing.

If you select Scene you can import a bunch of 3D formats which includes ACIS SAT, Parasolid, STEP, IGES, Pro/ENGINEER unecrypted (prior to 200oi) and CATIA V4. For an added cost (IronCAD hasn’t got back to me on exactly how much) you can import CATIA V5, Pro/ENGINEER encrypted, NX, SolidWorks and Inventor. This is what the File Import drop down looks like.

This is how I created a detailed 2D drawing of a part modeled in SolidWorks. I started out with one of the SolidWorks 2011 sample files – a two bolt flange.

Since the IRONCAD DRAFT beta that I was given didn’t have the SolidWorks importer, I exported out a Parasolid file from SolidWorks 2011 and imported it into IRONCAD DRAFT.

Next I created a new CAXA Draft 2D drawing. I then clicked on the 3D Interface tab on the ribbon.

As the name of the tab suggests, the commands on it are the interface to the 3D side of things. I clicked on Standard View and a dialog box popped up asking me to select the views I wanted to create in my drawing. I picked the standard 3 views and the isometric view.

After I hit OK I used the mouse to drop the four views into the 2D drawing.

Using the commands on the Dimension tab I then created a few dimensions.

Assembly Design

Now comes the fun part. Like I said earlier, IRONCAD DRAFT is not just an AutoCAD clone and now you will see why. This neat little product allows you to do assembly design using standard components. Yes, you read that right. This 2D drafting product can do 3D assembly design. Here is how. IRONCAD DRAFT comes with something called a Catalog Browser which is basically a collection of standard components like bearings, gears, fasteners, etc.

You can simply drag and drop these standard components in the 3D scene. I clicked the fastener icon in the Catalog Browser and dragged it onto one of the cylindrical holes of the flange. This popped up a dialog box asking me to configure my fastener.

I could choose between bolts, screws, nuts, washer, pins and rings. I decided to add a bolt and since I picked on a cylindrical face, the software figured out the body diameter of the bolt and did not allow me to change it. While I was at it I decided to added a standard nut and a plain washer as well. I hit OK and a new bolt assembly was added to my scene.

I repeated this for the other hole and added another bolt assembly to the scene. Plain and simple drag, drop and configure. The Scene Browser updated itself accordingly.

I saved the file and switched to my 2D drawing window. Since associativity is maintained between the 3D scene and the 2D drawing, I was asked if I wanted to update the drawing with the two new bolt assemblies. I say yes and the two bolt assemblies were added to the 2D drawing.

You can do a lot more like create a 3D BOM, generate part numbers automatically or manually, etc. The best part is you are not limited to the standard components that come with IRONCAD DRAFT. You can create your own standard components and add them to the Catalog Browser. This opens up a range of possibilities. For example, you can build full blown assemblies from your own standard components solely by drag, drop and configure. With a little bit of training a sales person can do this in front of a customer at his site. Essentially you can make IRONCAD DRAFT something like a product configurator with the added benefit of being able to have dynamic components. Like I said, this $595 product is much more than an AutoCAD clone.

And that’s not all. There is a Visualization tab in the ribbon that has commands to set up material properties for realistic rendering and even animations. There is so much more that I haven’t got into here.

Who is IRONCAD DRAFT for?

A 2D user not accustomed to 3D design can use 3D models from other people to create 2D technical documentation. He can even take it further to create assembly instructions, renderings and animations. Sales people can use IRONCAD DRAFT as an intelligent product configurator. Companies that have 3D designers and 2D detailers can split the work accordingly. Apart from saving to its own native EXB format, IRONCAD DRAFT can write to AutoCAD DWG and 2D IGES. Here is the IRONCAD DRAFT 2D drawing in AutoCAD 2011.

This is a standalone product and does not need IRONCAD or INOVATE to be installed on the computer. And since it comes with translators for all the main MCAD systems it can be deployed just about in any company that needs to do 2D detailing and 3D assembly modeling. It also comes with a API and can be customized which makes it very interesting for third party plug-in developers like me.

Bottom line, I think for $595 IRONCAD DRAFT is great value for money.

Download 30 day trial

Prices

  • IRONCAD – $3,995
  • INOVATE – $1,295
  • IRONCAD DRAFT – $595
  • Anonymous

    Hi Deelip,

    I little bit confuse comparing these two images ( The Menu & Ribbon Command ) :

    http://www.deelip.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/130.jpg
    http://www.deelip.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/127.jpg

    On the top have the same label : “IRONCAD DRAFT”.
    But why the toolbar on the command manager different ?

  • http://www.deelip.com Deelip Menezes

    The first is the CAXA Draft environment, whereas the second is the IRONCAD environment. IRONCAD DRAFT is actually the 3D part of IRONCAD and the 2D part of CAXA Draft put together.

  • Walt Bednarz

    This sounds great, but I have to mention this. Solid Edge 2D is free. Sure there are a lot of free 2D programs out there. However, Solid Edge Free 2D shares the exact same interface as the 2D product used in the purchased 3D product. A company could have users on 10 purchased seats using the 3d product and another 10 users using the free 2d product. They can share knowledge and experience because it is the same tool. The 2D piece part drawings and convert them to 3d models. Yes, we have seen everyone do that, but it is amazingly easy and much more useful in direct editing environments such as ST3. Solid Edge Free 2D also has a huge library of diagram components (autocad blocks) for P&ID, electrical controls, and fluid controls. Once again, free.

  • Walt Bednarz

    If you want to learn more about Solid Edge Free 2D, I put tutorials and links on my site: http://www.deandm.com/index.php?page=free_engineering_tools_details&fsw_id=se2d

  • http://www.deelip.com Deelip Menezes

    Can the free Solid Edge 2D product import 3D data from other MCAD systems? Or is it tied to Solid Edge only?

  • Anonymous

    Hi Deelip,

    For IRONCAD DRAFT need IRONCAD 3D installed to be able import data from other MCAD and neutral format ?

    As long as I know, 2D Editor can import native solidworks file but need solidworks installed on the same machine.

  • http://www.deelip.com Deelip Menezes

    No, like I said in my post, IRONCAD DRAFT is a separate product and does not need IRONCAD or INOVATE to be installed or licensed. The 3D importers are included in the $595 price. That’s why I think it is value for money.

    SolidWorks 2D Editor is a flavor of IntelliCAD that comes free with SolidWorks. There is no associativity between the SolidWorks models and the 2D drawings in DWG editor. Means if the SolidWorks model changes, the 2D drawing is not updated. 2D Editor is simply meant to open and edit DWG files that’s all.

  • Cary O’Connor

    IRONCAD DRAFT has the same 2D Enviornment as IRONCAD as well. Users in IRONCAD have all the same capabilities as IRONCAD DRAFT with more power of course (History, Direct Editing, SmartUpdate, etc.. refer to Deelip’s post on IRONCAD). Users that use the 2D in IRONCAD can easliy help other users in a company that only have IRONCAD DRAFT. IRONCAD DRAFT also will read the Native IRONCAD file and will maintain assocations to it. So when the 3D is changed, IRONCAD DRAFT will update the 3D and 2D to account for the changes. Also, IRONCAD DRAFT can open the Part/Assembly catalogs that users create in IRONCAD/INOVATE. As Deelip mentioned, users could build a dynamic configurator that allows users to simply drag from the catalog and drop in 3D. The Parts/Assembles can have intelligent snapping and variations to automatically align and size to other parts. Keep in mind, the snapping intelligent can be added to imported data as well and stored in catalogs (so it is not limited to IRONCAD users only). Any data created in IRONCAD DRAFT can be opened in the native IRONCAD if the users needs grow to a more powerful 3D/2D system. One of the main differences in IRONCAD DRAFT is the 3D portion of the product. Users can import 3D, interrogate (measure, COG, mass), build assemblies of multiple imported data (with BOM information), build automatic snapping rules, render, animate, export to facet or image formats, and leverage the 3D information in 2D for view creation and associations to the 3D when it is updated. Also, the 2D in IRONCAD DRAFT is very similar to the AutoCAD UI unlike the SolidEdge 2D. Being similar in UI makes it easier for users to learn and use the program (especially if you are an AutoCAD, AutoCAD LT, or clone user).

  • Cary O’Connor

    Note: IRONCAD DRAFT’s 2D also has support for CRX (similar to ARX) included in the base product.

  • Anonymous

    Hi Deelip,

    You can search on Google for “DWGeditor View Pallete”.
    I also found this pdf : http://files.solidworks.com/Supportfiles/Whats_new/2009/English/whatsnewhighlights.pdf

  • http://www.deelip.com Deelip Menezes

    Interesting. I didn’t know that. Should try it out sometime.

  • Cary O’Connor

    I suppose it may be limited to SW files. IRONCAD DRAFT can import most 3D formats and perform this capability and is not limited to IRONCAD scene files.

  • http://www.deelip.com Deelip Menezes

    Indeed. That’s the part I found most interesting.

  • Walt Bednarz

    Unfortunately, SE2D does not have that functionality. It has interoperability with 2d dxf, dwg and I believe the Microstation format (if I recall correctly, that would be dgn).

  • Kevin Quigley

    Looks like a great value product Deelip. I was especially amazed to see the ROMLUS .xmt format available as an import option! ROMULUS was something I worked on back in the mid 80s – on a main frame!

    This reminds me a bit of the old Ashlar-Vellum Neon software – that could open up 3D formats and create simple drawings, but this one looks a bit more expansive. I’ll need to investigate.

  • http://www.deelip.com Deelip Menezes

    Indeed. As a developer who offers data exchange solutions, I am looking at IRONCAD DRAFT in a different way myself.

  • Pingback: News Alert – IRONCAD DRAFT + Native Translators for $595 | Deelip.com

  • vipul

    IRON CAD have some other benefits also, but you explain great..




Archives

© 2014 Deelip.com. All Rights Reserved. Deelip.com is a registered trademark of Deelip Menezes. Log in - Designed by Gabfire Themes